Pages

Showing posts with label 1972 Bill Withers hit whose title precedes when you're not strong. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 1972 Bill Withers hit whose title precedes when you're not strong. Show all posts

Sunday, July 10, 2011

1924 Edna Ferber novel / MON 7-11-11 / 1972 Bill Withers hit / Pair of cymbals operated by pedal / Holder of birdseed / Icy expanse redundantly

Constructor: Ellen Leuschner

Relative difficulty: Medium

THEME: "Redundantly" — common two-word phrases that are (allegedly) redundant, with every clue ending, "redundantly"


Word of the Day: "SO BIG" (62A: 1924 Edna Ferber novel) —
So Big is a 1924 novel written by Edna Ferber. The book was inspired by the life of Antje Paarlberg in the Dutch community of South Holland, Illinois, a Chicago suburb. It won the Pulitzer Prize for the Novel in 1925. (wikipedia)
• • •

Seems like a fine Monday puzzle, though I've heard some summaries that were Not At All brief, so I'm not buying that one as much as the others. "Brief" is a relative term. A summary is by definition briefER than its object, but, depending on context, might not feel "brief" at all. Anyhoo, it's no big deal. I mean SOUTH is not literally DOWN except by map conventions. I suppose you could pick any of these apart if you really wanted to, but that seems mean-spirited and dark-hearted. My time was actually a little slower than normal, but I made some stupid mistakes and a Lot of typos, so I doubt this is any harder (or easier) than your typical (very easy) Monday.

Theme answers:
  • 17A: Place of refuge, redundantly (SAFE HAVEN)
  • 29A: Icy expanse, redundantly (FROZEN TUNDRA)
  • 47A: Synopsis, redundantly (BRIEF SUMMARY)
  • 64A: Where snowbirds head, redundantly (DOWN SOUTH)
Here's how a speed solver can go badly awry on a Monday:
  • Get confused by the gendering of 1D: Cowgirl's rope (LASSO)—no reason the rope can't belong to a girl, but in a world where the generic is usually masculine (sexist convention, but convention nonetheless), "girl" triggers thoughts of "there's a *girl's* rope?"
  • Think that the "celebrity" in 8D: Celebrity is a person (RENOWN)
  • Go with SNOBBY before SNOOTY (28D: Having one's nose in the air)
  • Spell RAZE "RASE" (31D: Bulldoze)
  • Fail to adjust the size of clue box to its biggest setting and thus not be able to read the full clue at 37A: 2006 title film character who says "Pamela! I no find you attractive anymore! ... Not!" (BORAT)
  • Try I FORGET before I FORGOT (44D: Excuse for a lapse)
  • Assume 55D: Pair of cymbals operated by a pedal is an S-ending plural (HI-HAT)
  • Fail, until the bitter end, to understand what 33D: Dead center? was all about (TOMB)

Bullets:
  • 29D: Holder of birdseed (FEEDER) — how is this different from [Birdseed holder]. Did you want me to think the answer was ERIC? If so, no dice!
  • 7D: Like a car with 20,000 miles on its odometer (USED) — that's a long (and arbitrary) way to go for USED.
  • 35D: Lighter-than-air aircraft (DIRIGIBLE) — Nice word. Is the helium considered part of the aircraft? Or is it considered something you put *in* the DIRIGIBLE (e.g. I don't consider gas, oil, transmission fluid as part of the car). Because the "aircraft" is "lighter-than-air" only with the helium inside.
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld

Followers

Blog Archive